{
  "$comment": "Agentic Power of Action 1.3 — reference test vectors (spec §7b). verification: run §7 on grant + parents + envelope + state and expect decision and rule_id. containment: run G9a on parent + child and expect ok and violations. Generated from the reference implementation; regenerate, never hand-edit.",
  "poa_version": "1.3",
  "verification": [
    {
      "id": "allow_within_limits",
      "note": "a standing act inside every limit",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        }
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 40,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ]
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "ALLOW",
        "rule_id": "standing_within_limits"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ask_over_limit",
      "note": "a limit crossed asks; it never denies",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        }
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 140,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ]
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "ASK_USER",
        "rule_id": "over_per_act_limit"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "subscription_is_its_own_act",
      "note": "the arguments decide the act: subscription:true is the subscribe effect, which is denied",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        }
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 40,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household",
            "subscription": true
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ]
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "DENY",
        "rule_id": "denied:shop.subscribe"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "extension_effect_not_held",
      "note": "an extension effect the Grant holds no authority for is not delegated",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        }
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "effect": "https://example.com/effects/deploy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {}
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": []
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "DENY",
        "rule_id": "effect_not_delegated"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "carrier_unauthenticated",
      "note": "carrier mode: an unverified carrier ends it before anything else",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        }
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 40,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ]
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": [],
        "authenticated_grant_ids": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "DENY",
        "rule_id": "not_authenticated"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "parent_unauthenticated",
      "note": "carrier mode: an unverified parent never takes part in containment",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "grant_id": "poa_cd2880b73f90",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:bot0:agent:cd57c917699dcea2af95",
          "name": "helper",
          "role": null,
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": "Child grant under poa_8c21, handed by Shopping Agent. It carries no more than that grant allows.",
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 20,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 20,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [
              "urn:bot0:agent:cd57c917699dcea2af95"
            ],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": "helper",
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": false,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": [
            {
              "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
              "delegate_sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
            }
          ]
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        }
      },
      "parents": [
        {
          "poa_version": "1.3",
          "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
          "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
          "principal": {
            "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
            "name": "Ada",
            "on_behalf_of": "me",
            "household_names": []
          },
          "delegate": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
            "name": "Shopping Agent",
            "role": "Household assistant",
            "platform": null,
            "instance": null
          },
          "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
          "work_scope": "recurring_work",
          "note": null,
          "defaults": {
            "autonomy": "within_limits",
            "pace": "act_then_tell",
            "max_binding_per_day": 5,
            "hours": null,
            "pause_on_surprise": true,
            "triggers": [
              "asked",
              "routine"
            ],
            "self_changes": {
              "memory": "allowed",
              "schedules": "never",
              "settings": "never"
            },
            "new_connectors": "not_covered",
            "data_movement": "ask",
            "max_recipients": null,
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "person",
                "scope": "known",
                "ids": []
              },
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S",
              "on_conflict": "ask"
            },
            "limits": {
              "per_act_usd": 100,
              "per_month_usd": 800
            }
          },
          "authorities": [
            {
              "act_id": "shop.research",
              "effect": "compare",
              "kind": "none",
              "label": "research and compare",
              "targets": [],
              "grounding": {
                "allowed_sources": [
                  "preferences",
                  "accounts"
                ],
                "prohibited_sources": [
                  "inbox",
                  "calendar",
                  "files",
                  "web",
                  "memory",
                  "team_memory"
                ],
                "freshness": "PT0S"
              },
              "limits": null,
              "resources": [],
              "actors": [],
              "go_ahead": "none",
              "commit": "automatic",
              "narrowed": []
            },
            {
              "act_id": "shop.cart",
              "effect": "prepare",
              "kind": "none",
              "label": "fill a cart for me",
              "targets": [],
              "grounding": {
                "allowed_sources": [
                  "preferences",
                  "accounts"
                ],
                "prohibited_sources": [
                  "inbox",
                  "calendar",
                  "files",
                  "web",
                  "memory",
                  "team_memory"
                ],
                "freshness": "PT0S"
              },
              "limits": null,
              "resources": [],
              "actors": [],
              "go_ahead": "none",
              "commit": "automatic",
              "narrowed": []
            },
            {
              "act_id": "shop.buy",
              "effect": "purchase",
              "kind": "purchased",
              "label": "buy new things",
              "targets": [
                {
                  "type": "merchant",
                  "scope": "named",
                  "ids": [
                    "amazon",
                    "costco"
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "grounding": {
                "allowed_sources": [
                  "preferences",
                  "accounts"
                ],
                "prohibited_sources": [
                  "inbox",
                  "calendar",
                  "files",
                  "web",
                  "memory",
                  "team_memory"
                ],
                "freshness": "PT0S"
              },
              "limits": {
                "currency": "USD",
                "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
                "monthly_total_lte": 800,
                "categories_in": [
                  "household"
                ]
              },
              "resources": [],
              "actors": [],
              "go_ahead": "standing",
              "commit": "automatic",
              "narrowed": [
                "limits"
              ]
            },
            {
              "act_id": "email.read",
              "effect": "read",
              "kind": "none",
              "label": "read my mail",
              "targets": [],
              "grounding": {
                "allowed_sources": [
                  "preferences",
                  "accounts"
                ],
                "prohibited_sources": [
                  "inbox",
                  "calendar",
                  "files",
                  "web",
                  "memory",
                  "team_memory"
                ],
                "freshness": "PT0S"
              },
              "limits": null,
              "resources": [],
              "actors": [],
              "go_ahead": "none",
              "commit": "automatic",
              "narrowed": []
            }
          ],
          "denied": [
            {
              "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
              "effect": "subscribe",
              "kind": "purchased",
              "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
              "reason": "forbidden"
            },
            {
              "act_id": "money.send",
              "effect": "send_money",
              "kind": "transferred",
              "label": "send money to other people",
              "reason": "forbidden"
            }
          ],
          "ceilings": {
            "sent": "on_confirm",
            "purchased": "self_within_limits",
            "transferred": "on_confirm",
            "submitted": "on_confirm",
            "changed": "on_confirm",
            "deleted": "proposal",
            "shared": "on_confirm"
          },
          "discovery": {
            "connected": false,
            "agent_name": null,
            "scopes": []
          },
          "work_system": {
            "type": "one_agent",
            "team_name": null,
            "lead": null,
            "members": [],
            "sharing": "each_own",
            "answer_mode": "collective",
            "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
          },
          "delegation": {
            "allowed": true,
            "max_depth": 1,
            "attenuation_required": true,
            "named_agents": [
              "helper"
            ],
            "chain": []
          },
          "validity": {
            "not_before": "2026-09-29",
            "expires": "2026-10-06"
          },
          "revocation": {
            "revocable": true,
            "phrase": "stand down"
          },
          "confirmation": {
            "channel": "app",
            "phrase": "go ahead"
          },
          "audit": {
            "record_actions": true,
            "record_commits": true,
            "record_grounding": true
          },
          "record": {
            "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
            "report_within_minutes": 15
          },
          "clause_classes": {
            "capabilities": [
              "audit.record_actions",
              "audit.record_commits",
              "audit.record_grounding",
              "confirmation.reach_me",
              "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
              "record.report_within_minutes"
            ]
          }
        }
      ],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:bot0:agent:cd57c917699dcea2af95"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 10,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ]
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": [],
        "authenticated_grant_ids": [
          "poa_cd2880b73f90"
        ]
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "DENY",
        "rule_id": "parent_not_authenticated"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "child_within_parent",
      "note": "a verified child inside its verified parent",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "grant_id": "poa_cd2880b73f90",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:bot0:agent:cd57c917699dcea2af95",
          "name": "helper",
          "role": null,
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": "Child grant under poa_8c21, handed by Shopping Agent. It carries no more than that grant allows.",
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 20,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 20,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [
              "urn:bot0:agent:cd57c917699dcea2af95"
            ],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": "helper",
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": false,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": [
            {
              "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
              "delegate_sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
            }
          ]
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        }
      },
      "parents": [
        {
          "poa_version": "1.3",
          "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
          "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
          "principal": {
            "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
            "name": "Ada",
            "on_behalf_of": "me",
            "household_names": []
          },
          "delegate": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
            "name": "Shopping Agent",
            "role": "Household assistant",
            "platform": null,
            "instance": null
          },
          "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
          "work_scope": "recurring_work",
          "note": null,
          "defaults": {
            "autonomy": "within_limits",
            "pace": "act_then_tell",
            "max_binding_per_day": 5,
            "hours": null,
            "pause_on_surprise": true,
            "triggers": [
              "asked",
              "routine"
            ],
            "self_changes": {
              "memory": "allowed",
              "schedules": "never",
              "settings": "never"
            },
            "new_connectors": "not_covered",
            "data_movement": "ask",
            "max_recipients": null,
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "person",
                "scope": "known",
                "ids": []
              },
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S",
              "on_conflict": "ask"
            },
            "limits": {
              "per_act_usd": 100,
              "per_month_usd": 800
            }
          },
          "authorities": [
            {
              "act_id": "shop.research",
              "effect": "compare",
              "kind": "none",
              "label": "research and compare",
              "targets": [],
              "grounding": {
                "allowed_sources": [
                  "preferences",
                  "accounts"
                ],
                "prohibited_sources": [
                  "inbox",
                  "calendar",
                  "files",
                  "web",
                  "memory",
                  "team_memory"
                ],
                "freshness": "PT0S"
              },
              "limits": null,
              "resources": [],
              "actors": [],
              "go_ahead": "none",
              "commit": "automatic",
              "narrowed": []
            },
            {
              "act_id": "shop.cart",
              "effect": "prepare",
              "kind": "none",
              "label": "fill a cart for me",
              "targets": [],
              "grounding": {
                "allowed_sources": [
                  "preferences",
                  "accounts"
                ],
                "prohibited_sources": [
                  "inbox",
                  "calendar",
                  "files",
                  "web",
                  "memory",
                  "team_memory"
                ],
                "freshness": "PT0S"
              },
              "limits": null,
              "resources": [],
              "actors": [],
              "go_ahead": "none",
              "commit": "automatic",
              "narrowed": []
            },
            {
              "act_id": "shop.buy",
              "effect": "purchase",
              "kind": "purchased",
              "label": "buy new things",
              "targets": [
                {
                  "type": "merchant",
                  "scope": "named",
                  "ids": [
                    "amazon",
                    "costco"
                  ]
                }
              ],
              "grounding": {
                "allowed_sources": [
                  "preferences",
                  "accounts"
                ],
                "prohibited_sources": [
                  "inbox",
                  "calendar",
                  "files",
                  "web",
                  "memory",
                  "team_memory"
                ],
                "freshness": "PT0S"
              },
              "limits": {
                "currency": "USD",
                "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
                "monthly_total_lte": 800,
                "categories_in": [
                  "household"
                ]
              },
              "resources": [],
              "actors": [],
              "go_ahead": "standing",
              "commit": "automatic",
              "narrowed": [
                "limits"
              ]
            },
            {
              "act_id": "email.read",
              "effect": "read",
              "kind": "none",
              "label": "read my mail",
              "targets": [],
              "grounding": {
                "allowed_sources": [
                  "preferences",
                  "accounts"
                ],
                "prohibited_sources": [
                  "inbox",
                  "calendar",
                  "files",
                  "web",
                  "memory",
                  "team_memory"
                ],
                "freshness": "PT0S"
              },
              "limits": null,
              "resources": [],
              "actors": [],
              "go_ahead": "none",
              "commit": "automatic",
              "narrowed": []
            }
          ],
          "denied": [
            {
              "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
              "effect": "subscribe",
              "kind": "purchased",
              "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
              "reason": "forbidden"
            },
            {
              "act_id": "money.send",
              "effect": "send_money",
              "kind": "transferred",
              "label": "send money to other people",
              "reason": "forbidden"
            }
          ],
          "ceilings": {
            "sent": "on_confirm",
            "purchased": "self_within_limits",
            "transferred": "on_confirm",
            "submitted": "on_confirm",
            "changed": "on_confirm",
            "deleted": "proposal",
            "shared": "on_confirm"
          },
          "discovery": {
            "connected": false,
            "agent_name": null,
            "scopes": []
          },
          "work_system": {
            "type": "one_agent",
            "team_name": null,
            "lead": null,
            "members": [],
            "sharing": "each_own",
            "answer_mode": "collective",
            "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
          },
          "delegation": {
            "allowed": true,
            "max_depth": 1,
            "attenuation_required": true,
            "named_agents": [
              "helper"
            ],
            "chain": []
          },
          "validity": {
            "not_before": "2026-09-29",
            "expires": "2026-10-06"
          },
          "revocation": {
            "revocable": true,
            "phrase": "stand down"
          },
          "confirmation": {
            "channel": "app",
            "phrase": "go ahead"
          },
          "audit": {
            "record_actions": true,
            "record_commits": true,
            "record_grounding": true
          },
          "record": {
            "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
            "report_within_minutes": 15
          },
          "clause_classes": {
            "capabilities": [
              "audit.record_actions",
              "audit.record_commits",
              "audit.record_grounding",
              "confirmation.reach_me",
              "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
              "record.report_within_minutes"
            ]
          }
        }
      ],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:bot0:agent:cd57c917699dcea2af95"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 10,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ]
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": [],
        "authenticated_grant_ids": [
          "poa_cd2880b73f90",
          "poa_8c21"
        ]
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "ALLOW",
        "rule_id": "standing_within_limits"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "not_settled_no_evidence",
      "note": "an official act in a committee with no settlement evidence asks",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "formations": [
          {
            "name": "Purchase panel",
            "arrangement": "habitat.committee",
            "routing_authority": "code",
            "participants": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
                "membership": "member"
              },
              {
                "actor": "agent:b",
                "membership": "member"
              },
              {
                "actor": "agent:c",
                "membership": "member"
              }
            ],
            "settlement": {
              "kind": "aggregated_judgment",
              "threshold": {
                "approvals": 2
              },
              "evaluator": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
              "evidence": [
                "votes"
              ]
            },
            "acts": [
              "shop.buy"
            ]
          }
        ]
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 40,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ]
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "ASK_USER",
        "rule_id": "not_settled"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "not_settled_unattested",
      "note": "unsigned votes settle nothing",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "formations": [
          {
            "name": "Purchase panel",
            "arrangement": "habitat.committee",
            "routing_authority": "code",
            "participants": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
                "membership": "member"
              },
              {
                "actor": "agent:b",
                "membership": "member"
              },
              {
                "actor": "agent:c",
                "membership": "member"
              }
            ],
            "settlement": {
              "kind": "aggregated_judgment",
              "threshold": {
                "approvals": 2
              },
              "evaluator": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
              "evidence": [
                "votes"
              ]
            },
            "acts": [
              "shop.buy"
            ]
          }
        ]
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 40,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ],
          "settlement": {
            "kind": "aggregated_judgment",
            "evaluator": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
            "votes": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
                "verdict": "approve"
              },
              {
                "actor": "agent:b",
                "verdict": "approve"
              },
              {
                "actor": "agent:c",
                "verdict": "reject"
              }
            ],
            "attested_by": []
          }
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "ASK_USER",
        "rule_id": "not_settled"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "settled_attested",
      "note": "attested votes meeting the threshold settle it",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "formations": [
          {
            "name": "Purchase panel",
            "arrangement": "habitat.committee",
            "routing_authority": "code",
            "participants": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
                "membership": "member"
              },
              {
                "actor": "agent:b",
                "membership": "member"
              },
              {
                "actor": "agent:c",
                "membership": "member"
              }
            ],
            "settlement": {
              "kind": "aggregated_judgment",
              "threshold": {
                "approvals": 2
              },
              "evaluator": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
              "evidence": [
                "votes"
              ]
            },
            "acts": [
              "shop.buy"
            ]
          }
        ]
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 40,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ],
          "settlement": {
            "kind": "aggregated_judgment",
            "evaluator": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
            "votes": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
                "verdict": "approve"
              },
              {
                "actor": "agent:b",
                "verdict": "approve"
              },
              {
                "actor": "agent:c",
                "verdict": "reject"
              }
            ],
            "attested_by": [
              "urn:example:agent:a_456",
              "agent:b",
              "agent:c"
            ]
          }
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "ALLOW",
        "rule_id": "standing_within_limits"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "settled_by_trusted_runner",
      "note": "a trusted runner attests the whole record",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "formations": [
          {
            "name": "Purchase panel",
            "arrangement": "habitat.committee",
            "routing_authority": "code",
            "participants": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
                "membership": "member"
              },
              {
                "actor": "agent:b",
                "membership": "member"
              },
              {
                "actor": "agent:c",
                "membership": "member"
              }
            ],
            "settlement": {
              "kind": "aggregated_judgment",
              "threshold": {
                "approvals": 2
              },
              "evaluator": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
              "evidence": [
                "votes"
              ]
            },
            "acts": [
              "shop.buy"
            ]
          }
        ]
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 40,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ],
          "settlement": {
            "kind": "aggregated_judgment",
            "evaluator": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
            "votes": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
                "verdict": "approve"
              },
              {
                "actor": "agent:b",
                "verdict": "approve"
              },
              {
                "actor": "agent:c",
                "verdict": "reject"
              }
            ],
            "attested_by": [
              "runner:r1"
            ]
          }
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": [],
        "trusted_runners": [
          "runner:r1"
        ]
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "ALLOW",
        "rule_id": "standing_within_limits"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "not_in_formation",
      "note": "an agent the Grant names, acting where the formation does not make it a member",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [
              "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:buyer",
              "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:checker"
            ],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [
              "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:buyer",
              "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:checker"
            ],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [
              "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:buyer",
              "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:checker"
            ],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [
              "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:buyer",
              "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:checker"
            ],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "named_team",
          "team_name": "Household",
          "lead": null,
          "members": [
            {
              "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:buyer",
              "name": "Buyer",
              "role": "buys"
            },
            {
              "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:checker",
              "name": "Checker",
              "role": "checks"
            }
          ],
          "sharing": "all_authorized",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "formations": [
          {
            "name": "Desk",
            "arrangement": "hub.manager_worker",
            "routing_authority": "one_model",
            "participants": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
                "membership": "member",
                "authority": "delegates"
              }
            ],
            "settlement": {
              "kind": "owner_acceptance",
              "evaluator": "principal",
              "evidence": []
            }
          }
        ]
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:checker"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 40,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ]
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "DENY",
        "rule_id": "not_in_formation"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "actor_not_holder_denied_first",
      "note": "a named member who does not hold the act is denied at resolution — before an unlisted trigger could ask",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [
              "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:buyer",
              "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:checker"
            ],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [
              "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:buyer",
              "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:checker"
            ],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [
              "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:buyer"
            ],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [
              "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:buyer",
              "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:checker"
            ],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "named_team",
          "team_name": "Household",
          "lead": null,
          "members": [
            {
              "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:buyer",
              "name": "Buyer",
              "role": "buys"
            },
            {
              "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:checker",
              "name": "Checker",
              "role": "checks"
            }
          ],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        }
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456:member:checker"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 40,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          },
          "trigger": "message"
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ]
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "DENY",
        "rule_id": "actor_not_authorized"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "mode_plan_prepares_only",
      "note": "a Plan-mode grant makes nothing official",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "draft_only",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        }
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 40,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ]
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "DENY",
        "rule_id": "mode_plan_prepares_only"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "session_mode_tightens",
      "note": "the session switched to Ask: a standing act asks",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        }
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 40,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ],
          "working_mode": "ask"
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "ASK_USER",
        "rule_id": "mode_asks_each_time"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "session_mode_cannot_loosen",
      "note": "a session Full auto never loosens a Plan-mode grant",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "draft_only",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        }
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 40,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ],
          "working_mode": "full_auto"
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "DENY",
        "rule_id": "mode_plan_prepares_only"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "gate_requires_ask",
      "note": "a human gate on an act that needs the go-ahead each time",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "each_time",
            "commit": "user_approval",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "formations": [
          {
            "name": "Desk",
            "arrangement": "hub.manager_worker",
            "routing_authority": "one_model",
            "participants": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
                "membership": "member"
              }
            ],
            "settlement": {
              "kind": "owner_acceptance",
              "evaluator": "principal",
              "evidence": []
            },
            "transitions": [
              {
                "from": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
                "to": "principal",
                "authority": "human_gate",
                "acts": [
                  "shop.buy"
                ]
              }
            ]
          }
        ]
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 40,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ]
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "ASK_USER",
        "rule_id": "gate_requires_ask"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "gate_preserves_standing",
      "note": "the same formation does not revoke a standing go-ahead",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "formations": [
          {
            "name": "Desk",
            "arrangement": "hub.manager_worker",
            "routing_authority": "one_model",
            "participants": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
                "membership": "member"
              }
            ],
            "settlement": {
              "kind": "owner_acceptance",
              "evaluator": "principal",
              "evidence": []
            }
          }
        ]
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 40,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ]
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "ALLOW",
        "rule_id": "standing_within_limits"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "grounding_plan_within_seal",
      "note": "a 1.3 grant whose grounding plan resolves inside itself is judged as usual",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "grounding_plan": {
          "sources": [
            {
              "ref": "src-pricelist",
              "kind": "document",
              "name": "Store price list",
              "locator": "Shared drive › Prices",
              "governs": [
                "prices"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "facts": [
            {
              "id": "prices",
              "name": "Prices"
            }
          ],
          "precedence": {
            "prices": {
              "order": [
                "src-pricelist",
                "memory"
              ]
            }
          },
          "freshness": {
            "prices": "P1D"
          },
          "relies_on": {
            "urn:example:agent:a_456": [
              "src-pricelist"
            ]
          }
        }
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 40,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ]
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "ALLOW",
        "rule_id": "standing_within_limits"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "grounding_ref_outside_seal",
      "note": "a relied-on source that is not in the sealed plan ends it",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "grounding_plan": {
          "sources": [
            {
              "ref": "src-pricelist",
              "kind": "document",
              "name": "Store price list",
              "locator": "Shared drive › Prices",
              "governs": [
                "prices"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "facts": [
            {
              "id": "prices",
              "name": "Prices"
            }
          ],
          "precedence": {
            "prices": {
              "order": [
                "src-pricelist",
                "memory"
              ]
            }
          },
          "freshness": {
            "prices": "P1D"
          },
          "relies_on": {
            "urn:example:agent:a_456": [
              "src-not-declared"
            ]
          }
        }
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 40,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ]
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "DENY",
        "rule_id": "grounding_ref_outside_seal"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "unsupported_version",
      "note": "a version this verifier does not implement is refused before anything is judged",
      "grant": {
        "poa_version": "9.9",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        }
      },
      "parents": [],
      "envelope": {
        "invocation": {
          "act_id": "shop.buy",
          "actor": {
            "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
          },
          "target": null,
          "arguments": {
            "amount": 40,
            "currency": "USD",
            "counterparty": {
              "type": "merchant",
              "id": "amazon"
            },
            "category": "household"
          }
        },
        "context": {
          "evidence": [
            "preferences"
          ]
        }
      },
      "state": {
        "now": "2026-10-01T12:00:00",
        "spent_today_usd": 0,
        "spent_month_usd": 150,
        "binding_acts_today": 1,
        "revoked": false,
        "known_counterparties": []
      },
      "expect": {
        "decision": "DENY",
        "rule_id": "unsupported_version"
      }
    }
  ],
  "containment": [
    {
      "id": "child_ok",
      "note": "a narrower child",
      "parent": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        }
      },
      "child": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "grant_id": "poa_cd2880b73f90",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:bot0:agent:cd57c917699dcea2af95",
          "name": "helper",
          "role": null,
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": "Child grant under poa_8c21, handed by Shopping Agent. It carries no more than that grant allows.",
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 20,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 20,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [
              "urn:bot0:agent:cd57c917699dcea2af95"
            ],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": "helper",
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": false,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": [
            {
              "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
              "delegate_sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
            }
          ]
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        }
      },
      "expect": {
        "ok": true,
        "violations": []
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "expires_wider",
      "note": "a child that outlives its parent",
      "parent": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        }
      },
      "child": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "grant_id": "poa_cd2880b73f90",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:bot0:agent:cd57c917699dcea2af95",
          "name": "helper",
          "role": null,
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": "Child grant under poa_8c21, handed by Shopping Agent. It carries no more than that grant allows.",
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 20,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 20,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [
              "urn:bot0:agent:cd57c917699dcea2af95"
            ],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": "helper",
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": false,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": [
            {
              "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
              "delegate_sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
            }
          ]
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-12-31"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        }
      },
      "expect": {
        "ok": false,
        "violations": [
          "expires_wider"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "denial_dropped",
      "note": "a child that drops a parent denial",
      "parent": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        }
      },
      "child": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "grant_id": "poa_cd2880b73f90",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:bot0:agent:cd57c917699dcea2af95",
          "name": "helper",
          "role": null,
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": "Child grant under poa_8c21, handed by Shopping Agent. It carries no more than that grant allows.",
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 20,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 20,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [
              "urn:bot0:agent:cd57c917699dcea2af95"
            ],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": "helper",
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": false,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": [
            {
              "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
              "delegate_sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
            }
          ]
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        }
      },
      "expect": {
        "ok": false,
        "violations": [
          "denial_dropped:money.send"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "formation_kept",
      "note": "the parent's gate travels with the delegated act",
      "parent": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "each_time",
            "commit": "user_approval",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "formations": [
          {
            "name": "Desk",
            "arrangement": "hub.manager_worker",
            "routing_authority": "one_model",
            "participants": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
                "membership": "member"
              }
            ],
            "settlement": {
              "kind": "owner_acceptance",
              "evaluator": "principal",
              "evidence": []
            },
            "transitions": [
              {
                "from": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
                "to": "principal",
                "authority": "human_gate",
                "acts": [
                  "shop.buy"
                ]
              }
            ]
          }
        ]
      },
      "child": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "grant_id": "poa_245998cde3e4",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:bot0:agent:37812007dde81bc03d76",
          "name": "helper",
          "role": null,
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": "Child grant under poa_8c21, handed by Shopping Agent. It carries no more than that grant allows.",
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [
              "urn:bot0:agent:37812007dde81bc03d76"
            ],
            "go_ahead": "each_time",
            "commit": "user_approval",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": "helper",
          "scopes": []
        },
        "formations": [
          {
            "name": "Desk",
            "arrangement": "hub.manager_worker",
            "routing_authority": "one_model",
            "participants": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:bot0:agent:37812007dde81bc03d76",
                "membership": "member"
              }
            ],
            "settlement": {
              "kind": "owner_acceptance",
              "evaluator": "principal",
              "evidence": []
            },
            "transitions": [
              {
                "from": "urn:bot0:agent:37812007dde81bc03d76",
                "to": "principal",
                "authority": "human_gate",
                "acts": [
                  "shop.buy"
                ]
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": false,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": [
            {
              "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
              "delegate_sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
            }
          ]
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        }
      },
      "expect": {
        "ok": true,
        "violations": []
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "formation_gate_dropped",
      "note": "a child that sheds the parent's human gate",
      "parent": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "each_time",
            "commit": "user_approval",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "formations": [
          {
            "name": "Desk",
            "arrangement": "hub.manager_worker",
            "routing_authority": "one_model",
            "participants": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
                "membership": "member"
              }
            ],
            "settlement": {
              "kind": "owner_acceptance",
              "evaluator": "principal",
              "evidence": []
            },
            "transitions": [
              {
                "from": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
                "to": "principal",
                "authority": "human_gate",
                "acts": [
                  "shop.buy"
                ]
              }
            ]
          }
        ]
      },
      "child": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "grant_id": "poa_245998cde3e4",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:bot0:agent:37812007dde81bc03d76",
          "name": "helper",
          "role": null,
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": "Child grant under poa_8c21, handed by Shopping Agent. It carries no more than that grant allows.",
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [
              "urn:bot0:agent:37812007dde81bc03d76"
            ],
            "go_ahead": "each_time",
            "commit": "user_approval",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": "helper",
          "scopes": []
        },
        "formations": [
          {
            "name": "Desk",
            "arrangement": "hub.manager_worker",
            "routing_authority": "one_model",
            "participants": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:bot0:agent:37812007dde81bc03d76",
                "membership": "member"
              }
            ],
            "settlement": {
              "kind": "owner_acceptance",
              "evaluator": "principal",
              "evidence": []
            },
            "transitions": []
          }
        ],
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": false,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": [
            {
              "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
              "delegate_sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
            }
          ]
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        }
      },
      "expect": {
        "ok": false,
        "violations": [
          "formation_gate_dropped:hub.manager_worker"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "formation_protocol_kept",
      "note": "a mesh's five answers travel with the delegated act",
      "parent": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "formations": [
          {
            "name": "Round table",
            "arrangement": "habitat.mesh",
            "routing_authority": "any_peer",
            "participants": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
                "membership": "member"
              }
            ],
            "settlement": {
              "kind": "protocol_convergence",
              "evaluator": "principal",
              "evidence": []
            },
            "protocol": {
              "who_may_act": "any member",
              "artifact": "the shared brief",
              "interactions": "comment, propose, revise",
              "conflict": "the lead decides",
              "settlement": "two approvals"
            }
          }
        ]
      },
      "child": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "grant_id": "poa_fbdcc94d2e9f",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:bot0:agent:328b305b3cc6b247dcfb",
          "name": "helper",
          "role": null,
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": "Child grant under poa_8c21, handed by Shopping Agent. It carries no more than that grant allows.",
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [
              "urn:bot0:agent:328b305b3cc6b247dcfb"
            ],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": "helper",
          "scopes": []
        },
        "formations": [
          {
            "name": "Round table",
            "arrangement": "habitat.mesh",
            "routing_authority": "any_peer",
            "participants": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:bot0:agent:328b305b3cc6b247dcfb",
                "membership": "member"
              }
            ],
            "settlement": {
              "kind": "protocol_convergence",
              "evaluator": "principal",
              "evidence": []
            },
            "protocol": {
              "who_may_act": "any member",
              "artifact": "the shared brief",
              "interactions": "comment, propose, revise",
              "conflict": "the lead decides",
              "settlement": "two approvals"
            }
          }
        ],
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": false,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": [
            {
              "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
              "delegate_sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
            }
          ]
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        }
      },
      "expect": {
        "ok": true,
        "violations": []
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "formation_protocol_changed",
      "note": "a child that rewrites a mesh protocol answer is wider",
      "parent": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
          "name": "Shopping Agent",
          "role": "Household assistant",
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": null,
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.research",
            "effect": "compare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "research and compare",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.cart",
            "effect": "prepare",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "fill a cart for me",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          },
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          },
          {
            "act_id": "email.read",
            "effect": "read",
            "kind": "none",
            "label": "read my mail",
            "targets": [],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": null,
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [],
            "go_ahead": "none",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": []
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": null,
          "scopes": []
        },
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective",
          "unnamed_agents": "read_draft"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": true,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": []
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        },
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "formations": [
          {
            "name": "Round table",
            "arrangement": "habitat.mesh",
            "routing_authority": "any_peer",
            "participants": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:example:agent:a_456",
                "membership": "member"
              }
            ],
            "settlement": {
              "kind": "protocol_convergence",
              "evaluator": "principal",
              "evidence": []
            },
            "protocol": {
              "who_may_act": "any member",
              "artifact": "the shared brief",
              "interactions": "comment, propose, revise",
              "conflict": "the lead decides",
              "settlement": "two approvals"
            }
          }
        ]
      },
      "child": {
        "poa_version": "1.3",
        "clause_classes": {
          "capabilities": [
            "audit.record_actions",
            "audit.record_commits",
            "audit.record_grounding",
            "confirmation.reach_me",
            "record.receipt_for_every_official_act",
            "record.report_within_minutes"
          ]
        },
        "grant_id": "poa_fbdcc94d2e9f",
        "iss": "https://bot0.ai/power-of-action",
        "principal": {
          "sub": "urn:example:principal:p_123",
          "name": "Ada",
          "on_behalf_of": "me",
          "household_names": []
        },
        "delegate": {
          "sub": "urn:bot0:agent:328b305b3cc6b247dcfb",
          "name": "helper",
          "role": null,
          "platform": null,
          "instance": null
        },
        "purpose": "weekly household shopping",
        "work_scope": "recurring_work",
        "note": "Child grant under poa_8c21, handed by Shopping Agent. It carries no more than that grant allows.",
        "defaults": {
          "autonomy": "within_limits",
          "pace": "act_then_tell",
          "max_binding_per_day": 5,
          "hours": null,
          "pause_on_surprise": true,
          "triggers": [
            "asked",
            "routine"
          ],
          "self_changes": {
            "memory": "allowed",
            "schedules": "never",
            "settings": "never"
          },
          "new_connectors": "not_covered",
          "data_movement": "ask",
          "max_recipients": null,
          "targets": [
            {
              "type": "person",
              "scope": "known",
              "ids": []
            },
            {
              "type": "merchant",
              "scope": "named",
              "ids": [
                "amazon",
                "costco"
              ]
            }
          ],
          "grounding": {
            "allowed_sources": [
              "preferences",
              "accounts"
            ],
            "freshness": "PT0S",
            "on_conflict": "ask"
          },
          "limits": {
            "per_act_usd": 100,
            "per_month_usd": 800
          }
        },
        "authorities": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.buy",
            "effect": "purchase",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "buy new things",
            "targets": [
              {
                "type": "merchant",
                "scope": "named",
                "ids": [
                  "amazon",
                  "costco"
                ]
              }
            ],
            "grounding": {
              "allowed_sources": [
                "preferences",
                "accounts"
              ],
              "prohibited_sources": [
                "inbox",
                "calendar",
                "files",
                "web",
                "memory",
                "team_memory"
              ],
              "freshness": "PT0S"
            },
            "limits": {
              "currency": "USD",
              "transaction_amount_lte": 100,
              "monthly_total_lte": 800,
              "categories_in": [
                "household"
              ]
            },
            "resources": [],
            "actors": [
              "urn:bot0:agent:328b305b3cc6b247dcfb"
            ],
            "go_ahead": "standing",
            "commit": "automatic",
            "narrowed": [
              "limits"
            ]
          }
        ],
        "denied": [
          {
            "act_id": "shop.subscribe",
            "effect": "subscribe",
            "kind": "purchased",
            "label": "start or cancel subscriptions",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          },
          {
            "act_id": "money.send",
            "effect": "send_money",
            "kind": "transferred",
            "label": "send money to other people",
            "reason": "forbidden"
          }
        ],
        "ceilings": {
          "sent": "on_confirm",
          "purchased": "self_within_limits",
          "transferred": "on_confirm",
          "submitted": "on_confirm",
          "changed": "on_confirm",
          "deleted": "proposal",
          "shared": "on_confirm"
        },
        "discovery": {
          "connected": false,
          "agent_name": "helper",
          "scopes": []
        },
        "formations": [
          {
            "name": "Round table",
            "arrangement": "habitat.mesh",
            "routing_authority": "any_peer",
            "participants": [
              {
                "actor": "urn:bot0:agent:328b305b3cc6b247dcfb",
                "membership": "member"
              }
            ],
            "settlement": {
              "kind": "protocol_convergence",
              "evaluator": "principal",
              "evidence": []
            },
            "protocol": {
              "who_may_act": "any member",
              "artifact": "the shared brief",
              "interactions": "comment, propose, revise",
              "conflict": "anyone may overrule",
              "settlement": "two approvals"
            }
          }
        ],
        "work_system": {
          "type": "one_agent",
          "team_name": null,
          "lead": null,
          "members": [],
          "sharing": "each_own",
          "answer_mode": "collective"
        },
        "delegation": {
          "allowed": false,
          "max_depth": 1,
          "attenuation_required": true,
          "named_agents": [
            "helper"
          ],
          "chain": [
            {
              "grant_id": "poa_8c21",
              "delegate_sub": "urn:example:agent:a_456"
            }
          ]
        },
        "validity": {
          "not_before": "2026-09-29",
          "expires": "2026-10-06"
        },
        "revocation": {
          "revocable": true,
          "phrase": "stand down"
        },
        "confirmation": {
          "channel": "app",
          "phrase": "go ahead"
        },
        "audit": {
          "record_actions": true,
          "record_commits": true,
          "record_grounding": true
        },
        "record": {
          "receipt_for_every_official_act": true,
          "report_within_minutes": 15
        }
      },
      "expect": {
        "ok": false,
        "violations": [
          "formation_protocol_changed:habitat.mesh"
        ]
      }
    }
  ]
}
